Michigan’s Power Lines Won’t Power the Future of Net Zero Anytime Soon

By CR News Reporter Joe Ross

In January, the Biden administration adopted ambitious decarbonization plans that aim to reach 100 percent clean electricity by 2035 and net-zero emissions across the economy by 2050. The widespread adoption of clean energy goals by many U.S. states and businesses is underway. Between 2001 and 2019, our nation’s level of electricity coming from renewable sources increased from 28 percent to 38 percent.

There are some challenges to the expansion of wind and solar energy.

First we must think about the current, most prevalent model. We know that the state’s power lines cannot handle the massive electric loads it will take to power electric vehicles and heat homes in the future. It’s created by coal or natural gas plants, and then it’s carried long distances by transmission lines to substations. The substations feed your neighborhood power lines, and subsequently your home.

In order to add wind and solar energy, wind and solar fields must be added, as well as transmission lines. In Map 1, the data map shows where our existing renewable solar and wind fields are. Map 2 shows where the additional renewable energy fields must be added to reach 100 percent renewable by 2050.

A decade long study by MIT shows that expanding the U.S. transmission grid will play a key role in decarbonizing the country’s electricity system. Our current system relies heavily on smaller power networks at the state and regional level. The benefits of nationwide transmission allows power-sharing across regions facing widely different weather systems that drive variation in wind and solar generation. Another important aspect to a national grid is it allows the construction of massive solar and wind farms that can be concentrated in the windiest and sunniest regions of the country. However, our current approach is in smaller farms that are spread out amongst each state, and this is a less efficient approach.

These massive, concentrated farms would reduce our dependency on “long-duration energy storage,” such as large scale battery storage, which have a dirty carbon foot print.

Unfortunately, state and private industry experts told the Michigan Propane Gas Association (MPGA) that building-out these new transmission lines will be very difficult and expensive. The land needed and material expenses are massive. This build-out is parallel to building hundreds of new roads across Michigan residents ’land. To complicate things further, a number of Midwest residents and elsewhere, are pushing back on solar and wind projects in Michigan, Indiana and Ohio. The massive scale of these new high-capacity electric transmission lines and spur lines will require large tracks of land cutting through Michigan forests and fields.

Industry experts are concerned that not all options are considered. “I worry our policy makers are overlooking tried and true clean energy like propane vehicles,” said Scott Underwood II, Vice President of the MPGA. “Michigan has over 10,000 vehicles fueled by propane that can be fueled at over 500 sites throughout the state.”

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) recognizes propane as a clean fuel. Tests demonstrate that propane emissions have 93% lower carbon monoxide, 73% lower hydrocarbons, and 57% lower nitrogen oxides than even the federal Clean Air Act standards.

Fact Checking & Research Support by Jon Suan

Map 1: Current locations of renewable power generation
(Solar and Wind)

Michigan’s Power Lines

Princeton’s projections for 2050 Net Zero Renewables
(White = 2050 projected expansions of renewable energy projects)

Michigan’s Power Lines